Why Young People Love Bad Movies: From ‘Reefer Madness’ To ‘The Room’
A lot of people can’t understand why someone would want to watch a bad movie – even one that’s “so bad, it’s good.” Yet many bad movies find a completely intentional audience, several years after the fact.TakeEd Wood. The filmmaker died obscure and broke in 1978. Now he’s a famous cult figure with an award-winning biopic to his name, whose movies are screened all over the world. The same thing is happening right now toTommy Wiseau, the strange (French? Polish? Extraterrestrial?) director behindThe Room. This film was laughed off the screen when it opened in 2003. But it’s since become a beloved midnight movie that inspired a hilarious tell-all book and now, a behind-the-scenes film with serious Oscar potential:The Disaster Artist.Whether we’re talking aboutPlan 9 from Outer Space,The Room, or some other amazingly bad movie, there’s always one thing in common: young people. Young people have been instrumental in the success of all these reclaimed trash masterpieces. This is no accident. Young people are the perfect audience for bad films, for several reasons. The most basic is that college students have a great time watching these movies with their friends and a whole lot of alcohol. Some like to hone their most creative insults on these failed works, treating it like a witty bloodsport. But there’s also an odd sincerity to this interest in bad movies, one that keeps young people coming back to poorly edited, horribly acted, and barely scripted films again and again.
A Brief History of Bad Movies
Bad movies can be hard to define. They’re often called midnight movies, cult movies, or B-movies interchangeably. But while a midnight, cult, or B-movie can be bad, not all bad movies fit those labels. The only real defining trait is critical scorn upon release. Shoddy production values and nonsensical scripts tend to help.Television had a not insignificant role in their rise. Between 1954 and 1955, actress Maila Nurmi introduced viewers to cheap, forgotten horror films onThe Vampira Show. Nurmi’s Vampira served as the guide to films such asThe Flying SerpentandDevil Bat’s Daughter, released a decade earlier to little fanfare. This kind of television series was unique for the time and given Vampira’s, well, vampy persona, it led to lots of copycats on local stations.Morgus the Magnificententertained New Orleans audiences with his strange experiments, whileZacherleywas the undertaker host to beat in New York and Philadelphia.But bad movies found an early audience in movie theaters as well, since they shared some overlap with exploitation movies. Exploitation movies had existed on the fringes of Hollywood since at least the 1930s. They rarely made it into mainstream theaters, because wide releases required a seal of approval from the Production Code Administration, a censorship body that regulated movies from 1934 to 1968. Given the content of exploitation films – which ranged from drug frenzies to sex mania – they were hardly ever submitted for consideration to the PCA. But they built a following, one that exploded in the 1960s after the censorship system collapsed.Midnight movies were also exploding in popularity around that time. Most people think midnight movies, at least as we know them, began in the 1970s with Alejandro Jodorowsky’sEl Topo. But the seeds were there in the previous decade. As Keith Phippsexplained over atThe VergeMike Gertz started showing avant garde films at midnight at his Cinema Theatre in Los Angeles in the 1960s. He got the idea to bundle a bunch of them into “Psychedelic Film Trips #1,” a package he sent to his uncle Louis Sher’s theaters, also to be played at midnight. These “psychedelic” films did well, and were soon playing across America.All these movies and shows paved the way for our modern fixation with bad movies – and young moviegoers have always been their biggest champions.
Young People and Bad Cinema: A Love Affair
Reefer Madness, first released in 1936, is a classic example of an exploitation film. It fit neatly into a subset of that genre: the cautionary tale.Reefer Madnesswarned viewers that just a few joints could lead to multiple deaths, insanity, and some seriously dementedpiano performances. Despite that ridiculous plot,Reefer Madnesslikely would’ve been forgotten, were it not for Keith Stroup. Stroup was a recent law school grad in 1970 when he founded the National Organization for the Reform of Marijuana Laws. As part of his fundraising for the group, he began screeningReefer Madness, which he had purchased from the Library of Congressfor $297. Young people thought it was a riot, especially when they smoked pot themselves, and it quickly became a hit in college towns.This is a pattern you see all the time with bad movies. They are mocked and/or forgotten upon release, only to be rediscovered by young audiences and given a second life. It was also a young fan who led so many people to Ed Wood’s filmography after the director’s death. Harry Medved developed a fascination with the filmmaker when he was just 17 years old. He and his brother Michael later bestowed top worst honors on Wood in their 1980 bookThe Golden Turkey Awards. The designation helped introduce new viewers to the eccentric director. The Medved brothers also hosted Ed Wood screenings at film festivals, brought weird clips from his movies onto daytime television shows, and developed a British seriesThe Worst of Hollywoodto showcase films likePlan 9 from Outer Space. HarryMedved remembersthe Ed Wood cult truly taking hold in the early 1980s at places like UCLA, where students held an All-Day Wood Marathon in Melnitz Hall.Perhaps no single person is more responsible for rescuing bad movies from obscurity than Joel Hodgson, the creator ofMystery Science Theater. Hodgson was 28 when the first episode aired on KTMA-TV. His series was, in a way, the spiritual successor toThe Vampira Show. Hodgson did not wear a low-cut black dress, opting for a jumpsuit instead, but he did introduce his viewers to dozens of old, obscure films. Or, as the opening credits put it, “cheesy movies – the worst we can find.” As his alter ego Joel Robinson, Hodgson was subjected to the movies as a torture device, but ended up enjoying them instead, riffing throughout their runtime with his robot pals. Over the course of ten seasons and a recent revival,MST3Kbrought mass attention to now-canon bad movies, likeManos: The Hands of Fate.WhenMST3Kwriter Frank Conniff decided they should featureManos, the movie had been totally abandoned since its 1966 premiere. Why?Manoswas made by a salesman on a bet. It concerned a polyamorous cult, but featured seemingly endless, aimless shots of a family driving. The first screeningmade its child star cry. But its appearance onMystery Science Theater 3000brought it instant fame. TheManosepisode becamethe most popular DVDin theMST3Kcatalog, leading to a documentary (Hotel Torgo) and a meticulous restoration of the original 16mmManosprint.Who undertook that restoration? A 26-year-old film school graduate namedBen Solovey.As these examples show, awful-awesome movies were not, historically, the easiest to find. Fans had to read the right books, watch the right shows, or go to the correct campus screenings if they wanted to discover great bad movies. But streaming platforms have made it simpler for young audiences to find and boost their next favorite bomb. Many diehard fans ofThe Roomwill tell you that they saw the “You are tearing me apart, Lisa!” clip on YouTube before they ever saw the whole film. The same is true for the ubiquitous “They’re eating her!” scene fromTroll 2.
Why Young People Love Bad Movies
The obvious question is, “Why do people watch this garbage?” It’s been posed by scholars and concerned loved ones alike. A recent study in the journalPoeticsgave an academic reason. People who like “trash films,” it reasoned, tend to be film buffs. They enjoy “a broad spectrum of art and media across the traditional boundaries of high and popular culture.” A movie that pushes the traditional boundaries of pop culture could be an avant garde film likeMeshes of the Afternoon. Or it could beBirdemic. The good news is that, either way, it’s an indication of intelligence. (So if you like bad movies, you’rebasically a genius.)Ironic viewing is obviously a factor here, which has led some people to argue young people are being unbearably hip. In her bookNo Logo, Naomi Klein suggested this is exactly what happened withShowgirls. “Six months after the movieShowgirlsflopped in the theaters, for instance, MGM got wind that the sexploitation flick was doing okay on video, and not just as a quasi-respectable porno,” she writes. “It seemed that groups of trendy twenty-somethings were throwingShowgirlsirony parties, laughing sardonically at the implausibly poor screenplay and shrieking with horror at the aerobic sexual encounters."(This perception that young people are laughing derisively at bad movies is also what led Kurt Vonnegut to decline a dinner invitation from Hodgson, in a prettyincredible anecdote.)While snark is key for some viewers and some movies, none of that explains the genuine sincerity expressed by so many followers of terrible films. It’s all overBest Worst Movie, the documentary aboutTroll 2. Throughout the documentary, fans show off the sequel screenplays they’ve written, the tattoos they’ve inked on their arms, the costumes they’ve made. They reenact scenes to rapturous cheers. They lose their minds whenever actor turned dentist George Hardy, who played the father in the movie, makes an in-person appearance. They loveTroll 2for exactly what it is. “It’s genuine. There’s no irony going on,” one fan says. “A film that genuinely expresses a story. A totally whacked story.“Young fans have a deep affection for these movies because they see in them a silly sketch they shot with friends in high school. They watch a bunch of earnest people putting everything into a profoundly dumb idea, and recognize all the dumb ideas they’ve had. They know these people didn’t get famous, at least not in the way they imagined, from this ill-advised movie. But hey, theirShawshankparody didn’t get them anywhere, either.“There’s a certain nostalgia factor to it,” Solovey saidin an interview. “If you’ve ever picked up a video camera and tried to make something, you recognizeManos: The Hands of Fate.“Maybe you never dreamed upTorgoorNilbog, exactly, but someone did. For young people who love bad movies, that means something. Maybe even everything.
